Skip to content

Five Things to Check Before You Trust AI-Generated Machine Learning Code

Bruce Desmarais
December 8, 2025

When I teach courses on machine learning and advanced analytics, I allow students to use AI coding assistants, with the understanding that the students are ultimately responsible for their code and analyses being correct. Almost all of them use an AI assistant, and that’s given me a clear view of what these tools do well and where they tend to stumble.

LEARN MORE IN A SEMINAR WITH BRUCE DESMARAIS

Across assignments, the AI assistants produced code that ran and looked polished. But common problems kept appearing: strange parameter choices, little or no hyperparameter tuning, inconsistent train/test splits, evaluation metrics that didn’t fit the problem, and little attention to interpretation. In short, the code was a convenient first draft, but not something you’d want to trust as a final product.

Based on that experience, I’ve arrived at a simple five-point checklist that I now apply when developing code for machine learning with an AI assistant. Let’s walk through it:

1. Do the parameter settings actually make sense?

AI assistants tend to borrow library defaults. Sometimes that’s harmless; often it isn’t.

You’ll see:

  • Random forests with too few trees for large datasets.
  • Boosting models with generic depth and learning rates.
  • Neural networks with architectures that clearly don’t match the sample size.

These choices drive model behavior. So, before you run with AI-generated code, ask:

Are these parameters in line with what practitioners use in careful applications on similar problems?

If the answer is no, treat the script as an outline and revise it based on your own experience and the applied literature.

2. Did the assistant perform real hyperparameter tuning?

Many AI-generated scripts either skip tuning entirely or evaluate just a few different values of a single parameter. In most applied work, a minimal standard is a grid search over 2-3 plausible hyperparameters for the main algorithms, using cross-validation or a validation set.

This is often an iterative process. If the optimal hyperparameter setting lies on the boundary of the parameter grid, then you need to expand the grid. An important best practice for publishing applications of machine learning is to report the hyperparameter values that were evaluated and selected. A great way for practitioners to inform hyperparameter search is to reference published applications involving similar data and methods.

3. Are the train/test splits consistent?

I’ve seen many scripts that re-sample the training and test sets for each model and then compare performance across models. That’s not a meaningful comparison. Differences may simply reflect luck in the split rather than real performance gaps. A simple rule is to define a single, reusable split (or cross-validation scheme) and use that same training and test data for each model.

4. Are the evaluation metrics aligned with your scientific question?

Even when the modeling code looks reasonable, evaluation is often on autopilot. Assistants gravitate toward familiar metrics:

  • Accuracy or ROC-AUC for classification.
  • RMSE for regression.

Those can work fine, but they’re not always the best choice.

In imbalanced classification, a model can look excellent on accuracy while doing almost nothing for the rare class you care about. ROC-AUC can also be misleading with highly imbalanced data. When you prompt AI to generate code, it’s important to be clear about the scientific objective in the analysis (e.g., prediction, fitting interpretable nonlinear functions, anomaly detection), and then direct the assistant to use metrics that fit the objective.

5. Is there any serious interpretation?

Many AI-generated scripts stop once they report a performance number. For most research projects, that’s not enough. You usually want to know:

  • Which variables matter.
  • How changes in predictors move the outcome.
  • Where the model is confident and where it struggles.
  • How performance varies across demographics, geography, or time.

Simple tools like variable importance summaries, partial dependence plots, and case-level diagnostics are often essential for turning a trained model into a useful scientific or policy tool.

This is also where code links up with causal inference. When machine learning models are used to estimate things like nuisance functions, propensity scores, outcome regressions, or heterogeneous treatment effects, the quality and behavior of those models directly affect the quality of the causal estimates.

Evaluating how and where the models work matters just as much as headline predictive performance. For a deeper dive into this, check out Kosuke Imai’s upcoming Distinguished Speaker Seminar, Evaluating AI and Machine Learning Algorithms for Causal Inference.

Bringing It All Together

In my Statistical Horizons seminars on Machine Learning and Advanced Machine Learning, we spend a lot of time building full pipelines: from data preparation to model tuning, validation, and interpretation, often with causal questions in mind. AI coding assistants can speed up the scripting dramatically. They help you get from a blank file to a working prototype in minutes. But they don’t replace the statistical thinking and careful craftsmanship that are needed to meet a high standard of scientific rigor.

The five checks above are how I keep that thinking front and center. They’re a good reminder that “the code runs” is not the finish line. It’s the starting point.

Share

Comments

  1. The point about reusing the same train/test split also suggests a reporting check: before drafting the results section, reconcile every reported metric with the saved evaluation output and record which dataset version and split produced it. Otherwise a fluent summary can accidentally combine numbers from different runs. Keeping a small table of metric, split, run identifier and source output would make that mismatch easier to catch.

    Disclosure: I work on Data2Paper (https://datatopaper.com), which assists with research data analysis and manuscript drafts. I am reading this checklist from that workflow perspective; an automatically generated write-up still needs the researcher’s review of the underlying methods and results.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *